You might have heard that the Duggars are expecting their eighteenth child. And if you are on a moms’ board or you read the comments after news articles, you’ve probably read lots of criticism about their lifestyle and their choice to have so many kids. I know I have. I’ve seen assumptions made that they cannot possibly be good parents to that many kids. I’ve read comments saying “a vagina is not a clown car.” I’ve heard people say that they are disgusted by this family.
Let me preface this by saying that I don’t know much about the Duggars. I’ve never watched any of their TV shows (although now I want to!). I’ve read a few articles about them and perused their website, and I’ve read posts about them on moms’ boards. What I do know is that they are a large, fundamentalist Christian, homeschooling family. For religious reasons, they do not use birth control. They believe that it is up to God to determine their family size. They also love children. They use a “buddy system” in which their older children are responsible for some of the care of the younger children– helping them get dressed, teaching some homeschooling lessons, and doing household chores together. They live debt-free.
Now, I don’t agree with their religious or political beliefs, with the Quiverfull movement, with the gender roles they put their kids into. And I think it goes without saying that the J-name thing is just plain tacky. But honestly, I don’t understand the extreme vitriol I have seen directed at this family. And the more I think about it, Michelle Duggar is my freakin’ hero! I mean, if she can raise and homeschool 17 kids with no debt and her sanity intact, I want to know her secret so I can be more successful with my three!
In some ways the things that people bash the Duggars for are things that I and many people also do, but to a lesser degree. “Too many” kids? How many are too many, and who’s to say? Are my three too many? After all, it’s one more than replacing me and Adrian. Now, after my difficulties with this last pregnancy I think I am probably done with bearing kids, but really I wanted 4 or 5 kids. Is that too many? Some people, I know, think it is. I certainly don’t. Some people might say I can’t possibly give 5 kids, or even 3 kids, the attention they need. I know I can, though. The other day I met a mom of 6– a calm, well-put-together, not-completely-frazzled mom of 6– and all I felt about that number was envy and admiration. I’m sure others would make clown-car comments about her. On the other hand, I’m sure many moms of one can tell stories about all the criticism they’ve gotten for selfishly depriving their poor, poor only child of a sibling. Bottom line, the number of kids is nobody’s business but the mom’s and her partner’s.
I’ve heard it said that having so many kids taxes the environment. They buy most things second-hand, Michelle sews a lot of the kids’ clothes, they ride together in one vehicle, they buy in bulk, and I would guess they hand things down repeatedly. There are probably families with one child that tax the environment more. They have a 7000 sq. ft. house. Yes, that’s huuuge, but with their current 17 kids, that’s less than 400 sq. ft. per person. Most smaller families in the US use more space per person than that.
The buddy system? I babysat for my little sister all the time once I was old enough. As I started writing this post, Llani was calming my crying baby because I just needed a few minutes before I got up for the bazillionth time. She also helps Zeke get dressed quite often, and always begs to help with Luz. She taught Zeke the alphabet, and wants to teach him to read. She fixes sandwiches for him just like she does for herself. She keeps an eye on the baby when I take a shower. As she gets older I’m sure she’ll take on more responsibility with her younger siblings. I’m not sure how the Duggars’ buddy system works, but it’s probably different from our situation by just a matter of degree and formality. Don’t most families expect the older siblings to help out with the younger ones? Where is the magical line at which “helping out” becomes “parenting instead of the parents,” and who determines where that line is?
Michelle Duggar weans her babies at 6 months so her fertility will return. Again, not my choice, but 6 months of nursing is more than most babies in the US get.
There are a lot of different ways to parent, and we all make different choices. We moms are not always going to agree. I’m sure we all have hot-button issues– mine are breastfeeding, attachment, and violence as “discipline”– but I really don’t think family size has to be one of them. I wish people would realize that wanting a lot of kids does not make someone insane, nor does it make them a bad parent. It just makes them different.